On the prospects for the development of Russian economic law
https://doi.org/10.31085/2310-8681-2020-5-281-241-266
Abstract
The article examines the issues of interaction between law and economics through the prism of the formation of Russian economic law. The historical aspect is highlighted: the analysis of the pre-revolutionary legal doctrine and scientific sources during the Soviet development of the state. In the late XIX early XX centuries a general critical attitude to the Marxist idea of the primacy of the economic basis was formed. It was accompanied by the same skepticism about extreme liberalism, which advocates minimal government interference in the objective laws of economic development. Attention is drawn to the fact that during the Soviet period, by explaining a new branch economic law attempts were made to determine the limits of state influence on economic relations. In modern Russian law, in view of the constitutional consolidation of the canons of a market economy, a change of guidelines has taken place. New concepts have appeared economic constitution, constitutional economics, and economic analysis of law. There is an involvement of efficiency criteria in the evaluation process of the implementation of public power. The article also investigates the thesis about the formation of a new mega-branch of law economic law, which covers almost all aspects of the regulation of the national economy. Highlighted its positive (defining precise guidelines in the interaction of law and economics) and negative aspects (leveling the criteria for differentiation of branches of law).
About the Author
O. V. Romanovskaya
Penza State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Olga Romanovskaya (Penza, Russia) Doctor of Legal Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of Legal Disciplines
40 Krasnaja St., 440026, Penza
References
1. Amfiteatrov G. N., Gintsburg L. [Upravlenie khozyaystvom I khozyaystvennoe pravo za 15 let proletarskoy diktatury] of Economy and Economic Law Management in 15 Years of Proletarian Dictatorship / 15 Years of Soviet Construction. 1932 / https://naukaprava.ru/catalog/435/1108/5139/37212?view=1
2. Andreev V. K. [Mozhno li Grazhdanskiy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii nazvat’ ekonomicheskoy konstitutsiey] Can the Civil Code of the Russian Federation be called an economic constitution? (Razmyshleniya o zakonotvorchestve v oblasti ekonomiki) (Reflections on lawmaking in the field of economics) // Russian judge. 2003. No. 8.
3. Andreeva G. N. [K voprosu o ponyatii ekonomicheskoy konstitutsii] On the Notion of an Economic Constitution. // Constitutional and Municipal Law. 2010. No. 7. P. 9–13.
4. Andreeva G. N. [O kontseptsii ekonomicheskoy konstitutsii] On the Concept of Economic Constitution // Constitutional and Municipal Law. 2006. No. 1.
5. Andreeva T. K. [Voprosy kompetentsii arbitrazhnykh sudov v novom Arbitrazhnom protsessual’nom kodekse Rossiyskoy Federatsii] Issues of competence of arbitration courts in the new Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation // Economy and Law. 2002. No. 9.
6. Antonovich A. [Politseyskoe pravo i politicheskaya ekonomiya] Police Law and Political Economy. Kiev: University Printing House, 1883.
7. Arbitration process: textbook / A.V. Absalyamov, I. G. Arsenov, E. A. Vinogradova et al. V.V. Yarkov, main editor. 4-th edition, revised edition. М.: Infotropic Media, 2010. 880 p.
8. Ashmarina E. M., Ruchkina G. F. [Ekonomicheskoe pravo Rossiyskoy Federatsii (predmet i metod, sistema i struktura, istochniki pravovogo regulirovaniya)] Economic Law of the Russian Federation (Subject and Method, System and Structure, Sources of Legal Regulation) // State and Law. 2012. No. 8. P. 57–65.
9. Ashmarina E. M., Stakhov A. I. [Administrativno-ekonomicheskoe pravo Rossiyskoy Federatsii] Administrative-economic law of the Russian Federation // State and Law. 2018. No. 5. P. 37–43.
10. Becker Gary S. Human behaviour. An economic approach. М., 2003.
11. Becker Gary S. Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis Reviewed // Journal of Political Economy. 1962. Vol. 70. № 5. Рp. 9–49.
12. Brennan J., Buchanan J. The Reason of Rules. Constitutional Political Economy. Vol. 9 of the Ethical Economics Series: Studies in Ethics, Culture, and Philosophy of Economics / Ed. by A. P. Zaostrovtsev. SPb: Economic School. 2005. 272 p.
13. Chicherin B. N. [Kurs gosudarstvennoy nauki] A Course in State Science. Volumes I-III. Moscow, the printing house of the partnership I. N. Kushnerev and Co., 1894.
14. Chirkin V. E. [O terminakh “ekonomicheskaya konstitutsiya” i “konstitutsionnaya ekonomika”, a takzhe o rossiyskoy i zapadnoy nauke (otklik na stat’yu G. N. Andreevoy)] On the terms “economic constitution” and “constitutional economy”, as well as on Russian and Western science (response to the article by G. N. Andreeva) // Constitutional and Municipal Law. 2016. No. 3. P. 11–13.
15. Constitutional Economics / Editor-in-Chief G. A. Gadzhiev. М.: Yustitsinform, 2010. 256 p. / http://www.philosophicalclub.ru/content/docs/p5.pdf
16. Constitutional Legislation of the Russian Federation / Under the editorship of Yu. A. Tikhomirov. М.: Gorodets, 1999.
17. Doroshenko E. N. [Konstitutsionno-pravovoe regulirovanie ekonomicheskikh otnosheniy] Constitutional and Legal Regulation of Economic Relations / Thesis abstract. … Candidate of Juridical Sciences. М., 2004. 32 p.
18. Ershov V. V., Ashmarina E. M., Kornev V. N. [Ekomocheskoe pravo kak megaotrasl’ rossiyskogo prava: ego predemet I sistema] Economic law as a mega-branch of Russian law: its subject and system // State and Law. 2015. No. 7. P. 5–16.
19. Ershov V.V., Ashmarina E. M., Kornev V. N. [Ekonomicheskoe pravo i ekonomicheskoe pravosudie kak parnye kategorii. Klassifikatsiya ekonomicheskikh sporov] Economic law and economic justice as paired categories. Classification of economic disputes // State and Law. 2016. No. 8. P. 40–51.
20. Ershov V.V., Ashmarina E. M., Kornev V. N. [Ekonomicheskoe pravo kak nauka] Economic Law as a Science // State and Law. 2016. No. 3. P. 54–65.
21. Ershov V.V., Ashmarina E. M., Kornev V. N. [Ekonomicheskoe pravo: sravnitel’no-pravovoy analiz Germanii, Frantsii, Kitaya i Rossii] Economic Law: Comparative Legal Analysis of Germany, France, China and Russia // State and Law. 2014. No. 9. P. 53–64.
22. Ershov V.V., Ashmarina E. M., Saveliev V. N. [Sovremennoe ekonomicheskoe pravo kak rezul’tat geoekonomicheskoy, geokul’turnoy, geopoliticheskoy I geotekhnologicheskoy globalizatsii] Modern economic law as a result of geo-economical, geocultural, geopolitical and geotechnological globalization // State and Law. 2018. No. 7. P. 66–72.
23. Features of arbitration proceedings: textbook / O.V. Aboznova, Y.V. Averkov, N. G. Belyaeva et al; ed. by I.V. Reshetnikova. Moscow: Yustitsiya, 2019. Arbitration series. 324 p.
24. Filippova S.Yu. [Grazhdanskiy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii: peremeny. Kakim byt’ Grazhdanskomy Kodeksu?] The Civil Code of the Russian Federation: changes. What should the Civil Code be? // Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 11. Pravo. 2016. No. 2. P. 23–42.
25. Gadzhiev G. A. [Pravo I ekonomika (metodologiya)] Law and Economics (Methodology). М., 2016.
26. Gambarov Yu. S. [Grazhdanskoe pravo. Obshchaya chast’] Civil law. The General Part. St. Petersburg, 1911.
27. Gintsburg L. [Khozyaystvennoe stroitel’stvo pervogo goda proletarskoy diktatury (k voprosu ob istokakh sovetskogo khozyaystvennogo prava)] // Soviet State. 1932. No. 9–10 P. 79–102.
28. Goykhbarg A. G. [Khozyaystvennoe pravo RSFSR] Economic Law of the RSFSR. Vol. 1. Civil Code. Moscow, Petrograd, 1923. 216 p.
29. Gredeskul N. A. [Pravo I ekonomika] Law and Economics // Law. 1906. No. 40 / https://naukaprava.ru/catalog/435/936/3448/33081?view=1
30. Ioffe O. S. [O khozyaystvennom prave (teoriya i praktika)] On economic law (theory and practice) // Leningradsky juridical journal. 2005. No. 2. P. 177–195.
31. Ioffe O. S. [Pravovoe regulirovanie khozyaystvennoy deyatel’nosti v SSSR] Legal Regulation of Economic Activity in the USSR. L., 1959. 48 p.
32. Karapetov A. G. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava] Economic Analysis of Law. М.: Statute, 2016. 528 p. / https://m-lawbooks.ru/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/004-kniga.pdf
33. Khabrieva T. Ya. [Ekonomiko-pravovy analiz: metodologicheskiy podkhod] Economic and legal analysis: a methodological approach // Journal of Russian Law. 2010. No. 12. P. 5–26.
34. Khabrieva T.Ya. [Pravovye problemy fi nansovoy bezopasnosti Rossii] Legal Problems of Russia’s Financial Security // Bulletin of Economic Justice of the Russian Federation. 2016. No. 10. P. 48–54.
35. Khalfi na R. O. [Pravovoe gosudarstvo i ekonomika] Legal State and Econo mics / Socialist Legal State. Problems and Judgments. М., 1989. P. 121–132 / https://naukaprava.ru/catalog/435/1108/551684/62802?view=1
36. Khavanova I. A. [O teorii ekonomicheskogo analiza v nalogovom prave (kontseptual’nye osnovy)] On the theory of economic analysis in tax law (conceptual foundations) // Journal of Russian Law. 2015. No. 5. P. 111–124.
37. Kovalevsky M. [O zadachakh shkoly obshchestvennykh nauk] On the tasks of the school of social sciences. 1902.
38. Kurochkin S. A. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava kak perspektivnyy metod poiska resheniy aktual’nykh problem yurisprudentsii (na primere grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva)] Economic analysis of law as a promising method of fi nding solutions to current problems of jurisprudence (on the example of civil litigation) // Russian Law Journal. 2013. No. 2. P. 166–175.
39. Laptev V.V. [O sovetskom khozyaistvennom prave] On Soviet Economic Law // Soviet State and Law. 1959. No. 4. P. 70–87.
40. Laptev V.V. [Predmet i Sistema khozyaystvennogo prava] The Subject and System of Economic Law. М., 1969. 176 p.
41. Lorenz D.V. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz pozitsiy Konstitutsionnoho Suda RF otnositel’no zashchity prava sobstvennosti] Economic analysis of the positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation regarding the protection of property rights // Legislation and Economics. 2016. No. 1. P. 25–31.
42. Malko A.V. [Stimuly i ogranicheniya v prave] Incentives and Restrictions in Law. Revised and enlarged 2nd ed. М.: Yurist’, 2004. 248 p.
43. Mikhailovsky G.V. [Ocherki fi losofii prava] Essays on the Philosophy of Law. Vol. I. Tomsk, V. M. Posokhin’s bookshop edition, 1914.
44. Miroshnik S.V. [Ekonomicheskoe pravo v sisteme rossiyskogo prava] Economic law in the system of Russian law // Economic and legal issues. 2016. No. 1. P. 12–14.
45. Mozolin V. P., Barenboim P. D. [Grazhdanskiy kodeks kak “ekonomicheskaya konstitutsiya strany?”] The Civil Code as the ‘economic constitution of the country’? // Legislation and Economics. 2009. No. 4.
46. Pashukanis E. B. [Ekonomika i pravovoe regulirovanie] Economics and Legal Regulation // Revolution and Law. 1929 No. 4–5.
47. Pavlikov S. G., Avdijskij V. I. [O sootnoshenii ekonomiki i prava i tendentsiyakh konstitutsionno-pravovogo regulirovaniya ekonomicheskikh otnosheniy] On the ratio of economy and law and trends of constitutional-legal regulation of economic relations // State and Law. 2014. No. 11. P. 35–42.
48. Pokrovsky I. A. [Osnovnye problem grazhdanskogo prava. Petrograd, yuridicheskiy knizhnyy sklad] Basic Problems of Civil Law. Petrograd, Pravo Law Book Warehouse, 1917.
49. Pokrovsky P. [Bentam i ego vremya] Bentam and his time. Petrograd, printing house of A. E. Collins, 1916.
50. Pozner R. A. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava] Economic Analysis of Law. 2 volumes. SPb., 2004.
51. Pozner R. A. [Rubezhi teorii prava] Milestones of the theory of law. М., 2017. 480 p.
52. Romanovsky G. B. [Pravovaya okhrana materinstva i reproduktivnogo zdorov’ya] Legal Protection of Maternity and Reproductive Health. М.: Prospekt, 2016. 216 p.
53. Romanovsky G. B. [Pravovoe regulirovanie vspomogatel’nykh reproduktivnykh tekhnologiy (na primere surrogatnogo materinstva)] Legal regulation of assisted reproductive technologies (by way of example of surrogacy). М.: Urlitinform, 2011. 264 p.
54. Rubinstein B. M. [Sovetskoe khozyaystvennoe pravo: Ucehbnik dlya slushateley pravovykh shkol i vuzov] Soviet Economic Law: Textbook for students of law schools and universities. Leningrad Branch of the Communist Academy. Institute of Soviet Construction and Law. Moscow: Soviet Legislation State Publishing House, 1935. 182 p. / https://naukaprava.ru/catalog/435/1108/2871/19863?view=1
55. Rubinstein B. M. [Sovetskoe khozyaystvennoe pravo] Soviet Economic Law. М., 1935. 182 p. / https://naukaprava.ru/catalog/435/1108/2871/19863?view=1
56. Shastitko A. E., Pavlova N. S. [Pochemu ekonomicheskiy analiz] Why does economic analysis of law matter? // Law. 2018. No. 3. P. 57–66.
57. Shershenevich G. F. [Obshchaya teoriya prava] General Theory of Law. Volumes I–II. Moscow: The Bashmakovs’ Edition, 1910.
58. Shmakov A.V. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava] Economic Analysis of Law. Novosibirsk, 2005. 136 p.
59. Shmakov A.V., Epifanova N. S. [Ekonomicheskaya teoriya prava: uchebnik i praktikum dlya bakalavriata i magistratury] Economic theory of law: textbook and practice book for undergraduate and graduate studies. М.: Urait Publishing House. 2018. 420 p. / https://mx3.urait.ru/uploads/pdf_review/E373C704-8D4E4CFF-8995-299898FDE771.pdf
60. Sinitsyn S. A. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz prava i ego mesto v tsivilisticheskoy metodologii] Economic analysis of law and its place in civilistic methodology // Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2017. No. 2. P. 4–17.
61. Stammler R. Economy and Law According to the Materialist Conception of History. 2 volumes. SPb., 1907.
62. Stepanov D. I. [Ekonomicheskiy analiz korporativnogo prava] Economic Analysis of Corporate Law // Bulletin of Economic Justice of the Russian Federation. 2016. No. 9. P. 104–167.
63. Stuchka P. I. [Sotsialisticheskoe khozyaystvo i sovetskoe pravo] Socialist Econo my and Soviet Law // Revolution and Law. 1927. No. 1.
64. Suleimenov M. K. [Kak sozdavalsya Grazhdanskiy kodeks Respubliki Kazakhstan] How the Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan was created // Jurist. 2012. No. 1. P. 14–21.
65. Tadevosyan V. S. [Nekotorye voprosy sistemy sovetskogo prava] Some Issues of the System of Soviet Law // Soviet State and Law. 1956. No. 8. P. 99–108.
66. Uhlen Thomas S. [Teoriya ratsional’nogo vybora v ekonomicheskom analize prava] Rational Choice Theory in Economic Analysis of Law // Bulletin of Civil Law. 2011. No. 3. P. 275–315.
67. Volfson F. I. [Khozyaystvennoe pravo pervogo desyatiletiya] Economic law of the fi rst decade // Soviet Law. 1927. No. 6. P. 22–32.
68. Wolfson F. I. Economic Law of the First Decade // Soviet Law. 1927. No. 6. P. 22–32.
69. Wu В. Consumption and Management. Chandos Publishing, 2011. 510 р.
70. Zankovsky S. S. [Khozyaystvennoe pravo akademika V. V. Lapteva: retrospektiva, ukhodyashchaya v budushchee] Economic Law of Academician V. V. Laptev: a retrospective going into the future / [Tvorcheskoye nasledie akademika V. V. Lapteva i sovremennost’] Creative heritage of Academician V. V. Laptev and Modernity / Editors in Chief: A. G. Lisitsyn-Svetlanov, member of the Russian Academy of Sciences; N. I. Mikhailov, Doctor of Law, Professor; S. S. Zankovsky, Doctor of Law, Professor. М., 2014. 256 p. / http://igpran.ru/public/books/Pamyati_V.V.Lapteva.pdf
Review
For citations:
Romanovskaya O.V. On the prospects for the development of Russian economic law. Kazan University Law Review. 2020;5(3):241-266. https://doi.org/10.31085/2310-8681-2020-5-281-241-266
Views:
23
Email this article 