kulrKazan University Law ReviewKazan University Law Review2541-88232686-7885Казанский (Приволжский) федеральный университет10.30729/2541-8823-2022-7-3-102-116kulr-52Research ArticleСтатьиThe process of law formation: ontological, axiological and epistemological aspectsLangP.

Petr Lang, Doctor of Legal  Sciences, Associate Professor, Professor of the Department  of Civil and Arbitration Procedure; Head of the Department  of Analysis, Statistics and Court Proceedings Support

141 Soviet Army St., Samara, Samara region , 443090

petr.lang@mail.ruSamara State University of Economics; Eleventh Arbitration Court of AppealRussian Federation20223009202273102116Copyright © Lang P., 20222022Lang P.Lang P.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://kulr.elpub.ru/jour/article/view/52

The article considers the process of law formation as a two-unit process of spontaneous and planned-rational formation of legal norms system, providing the ordering of public relations under the influence of various factors of social development, receiving refraction in legally significant social interests and the subsequent reflection in the legal ideas. The ontological, axiological and epistemological aspects of this process are emphasized. By means of philosophical-legal methodology of law formation is presented in the form of twofold process of spontaneous and systematic-rational formation of legal norms, providing ordering of public relations.

law formationlaw makingontologyaxiologyepistemologylaw genesisReferencesBelyaev M. A. Postsovetskoe yuridicheskoe myshlenie i ego subekt [Post-Soviet legal mentality and its subject] // Problemy postsovetskoy teorii i filosofii prava: sb. st. [Problems of Post-Soviet theory and philosophy of law: collected essays.] M.: Yurlitinform, 2016. Pp. 4–29. (In Russian)Belyaev M. A. Postsovetskoe yuridicheskoe myshlenie i ego subekt [Post-Soviet legal mentality and its subject] // Problemy postsovetskoy teorii i filosofii prava: sb. st. [Problems of Post-Soviet theory and philosophy of law: collected essays.] M.: Yurlitinform, 2016. Pp. 4–29. (In Russian)Belyaev M. A. Sverkhregulirovanie: trudnosti problematizatsii [Overregulation: the difficulties of problematization] // Pravovoe regulirovanie: problemy effektivnosti, legitimnosti, spravedlivosti: sbornik trudov mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii (Voronezh, 02–04 iyunya 2016 g.) [Legal Regulation: problems of efficiency, legitimacy, justice: collection of essays of the international scientific conference (Voronezh, June 02–04, 2016)] / [redkoll.: V. V. Denisenko (otv. red.), M. A. Belyaev]. Voronezh: NAUKA-YuNIPRESS, 2016. Pp. 160–176. (In Russian)Belyaev M. A. Sverkhregulirovanie: trudnosti problematizatsii [Overregulation: the difficulties of problematization] // Pravovoe regulirovanie: problemy effektivnosti, legitimnosti, spravedlivosti: sbornik trudov mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii (Voronezh, 02–04 iyunya 2016 g.) [Legal Regulation: problems of efficiency, legitimacy, justice: collection of essays of the international scientific conference (Voronezh, June 02–04, 2016)] / [redkoll.: V. V. Denisenko (otv. red.), M. A. Belyaev]. Voronezh: NAUKA-YuNIPRESS, 2016. Pp. 160–176. (In Russian)Daneliya G. R. Osobennosti pravovogo regulirovaniya sotrudnichestva gosudarstv-chlenov ES v oblasti obshchey vneshney politiki i politiki bezopasnosti: avtoref. diss. … k.yu.n. [The specifics of the legal regulation of cooperation of EU member states in the field of common foreign and security policy: author's abstract of dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. Kazan, 2006. 19 p. (In Russian)Daneliya G. R. Osobennosti pravovogo regulirovaniya sotrudnichestva gosudarstv-chlenov ES v oblasti obshchey vneshney politiki i politiki bezopasnosti: avtoref. diss. … k.yu.n. [The specifics of the legal regulation of cooperation of EU member states in the field of common foreign and security policy: author's abstract of dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. Kazan, 2006. 19 p. (In Russian)Denisenko V. V. Pravovoe obshchenie v demokraticheskom grazhdanskom obshchestve [The legal communication in a democratic civil society] // Vestnik Voronezhskogo gos. un-ta. Seriya Pravo [Herald of Voronezh State University. Law Series]. 2018. No. 1. Pp. 29–36. (In Russian)Denisenko V. V. Pravovoe obshchenie v demokraticheskom grazhdanskom obshchestve [The legal communication in a democratic civil society] // Vestnik Voronezhskogo gos. un-ta. Seriya Pravo [Herald of Voronezh State University. Law Series]. 2018. No. 1. Pp. 29–36. (In Russian)Denisenko V. V. Problema yuridifikatsii s pozitsii kommunikativnoy teorii prava [The problem of jurification from the perspective of the communicative theory of law] // Sovremennoe otechestvennoe pravoponimanie: sostoyanie i perspektivy razvitiya: sbornik materialov Mezhvuzovskoy nauchnoy konferentsii [Modern native understanding of law: state and prospects of development: collection of materials of the Interuniversity scientific conference] / FGBOUVO “RGUP”, Tsentralnyy filial; otv. za vyp. R. R. Palekha, V. I. Filatov. Voronezh: OOO “Izdatelstvo RITM”, 2016. Pp. 42–49. (In Russian)Denisenko V. V. Problema yuridifikatsii s pozitsii kommunikativnoy teorii prava [The problem of jurification from the perspective of the communicative theory of law] // Sovremennoe otechestvennoe pravoponimanie: sostoyanie i perspektivy razvitiya: sbornik materialov Mezhvuzovskoy nauchnoy konferentsii [Modern native understanding of law: state and prospects of development: collection of materials of the Interuniversity scientific conference] / FGBOUVO “RGUP”, Tsentralnyy filial; otv. za vyp. R. R. Palekha, V. I. Filatov. Voronezh: OOO “Izdatelstvo RITM”, 2016. Pp. 42–49. (In Russian)Fisher R. Statisticheskie metody dlya issledovateley [The statistical methods for researchers]. M.: Gosstatizdat, 1958. 267 p. (In Russian)Fisher R. Statisticheskie metody dlya issledovateley [The statistical methods for researchers]. M.: Gosstatizdat, 1958. 267 p. (In Russian)Goldsmith L., Posner E. Th e Limits of International Law. New York: Oxford University Press. 2005. 272 p.Goldsmith L., Posner E. Th e Limits of International Law. New York: Oxford University Press. 2005. 272 p.Lang P. P. Pravovaya deyatelnost: aksiologicheskie i mirovozzrencheskie osnovaniya [The legal activity: axiological and attitudinal foundations]. Samara: OOO “Poligraficheskoe obedinenie “Standart”, 2021. 372 p. (In Russian)Lang P. P. Pravovaya deyatelnost: aksiologicheskie i mirovozzrencheskie osnovaniya [The legal activity: axiological and attitudinal foundations]. Samara: OOO “Poligraficheskoe obedinenie “Standart”, 2021. 372 p. (In Russian)Lang P. P. Pravovaya deyatelnost: aksiologicheskie i mirovozzrencheskie osnovaniya: avtoref. diss. … d.yu.n. [The legal activity: axiological and ideological foundations: abstract of the dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences]. Samara, 2022. 43 p. (In Russian)Lang P. P. Pravovaya deyatelnost: aksiologicheskie i mirovozzrencheskie osnovaniya: avtoref. diss. … d.yu.n. [The legal activity: axiological and ideological foundations: abstract of the dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences]. Samara, 2022. 43 p. (In Russian)Lang P. P. Pravovye tsennosti Evropeyskogo Soyuza: sovremennoe sostoyanie i transformatsiya [The legal values of the European Union: current state and transformation] // Aktualnye problemy pravovedeniya [Actual problems of jurisprudence]. 2021. No. 1(69). Pp. 4–9. (In Russian)Lang P. P. Pravovye tsennosti Evropeyskogo Soyuza: sovremennoe sostoyanie i transformatsiya [The legal values of the European Union: current state and transformation] // Aktualnye problemy pravovedeniya [Actual problems of jurisprudence]. 2021. No. 1(69). Pp. 4–9. (In Russian)Luhmann N. Selbstreflexion des Rechtssystems: Rechtstheorie in gesellschaft stheoretischer Perspektive [Self-reflection of the legal system: legal theory in a social theoretical perspective] // ders., Ausdiferenzierung des Rechts, Beitrage zur Rechtssoziologie und Rechtstheorie. Frankfurt [The differentiation of law, a contribution to legal sociology and legal theory. Frankfurt.], 1999. Pp. 419–450. (In German)Luhmann N. Selbstreflexion des Rechtssystems: Rechtstheorie in gesellschaft stheoretischer Perspektive [Self-reflection of the legal system: legal theory in a social theoretical perspective] // ders., Ausdiferenzierung des Rechts, Beitrage zur Rechtssoziologie und Rechtstheorie. Frankfurt [The differentiation of law, a contribution to legal sociology and legal theory. Frankfurt.], 1999. Pp. 419–450. (In German)Lutkova O. V. Osnovnye kontseptsii istochnikov mezhdunarodnogo prava: diss. … k.yu.n. [The basic concepts of the sources of international law: dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. M., 2004. 197 p. (In Russian)Lutkova O. V. Osnovnye kontseptsii istochnikov mezhdunarodnogo prava: diss. … k.yu.n. [The basic concepts of the sources of international law: dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. M., 2004. 197 p. (In Russian)Lysenko D. A. Problemy pravovogo statusa transnatsionalnykh korporatsiy: mezhdunarodno-pravovye aspekty: avtoref. diss. … k.yu.n. [The problems of the legal status of transnational corporations: international legal aspects: abstract of the dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. M., 2003. 33 p. (In Russian)Lysenko D. A. Problemy pravovogo statusa transnatsionalnykh korporatsiy: mezhdunarodno-pravovye aspekty: avtoref. diss. … k.yu.n. [The problems of the legal status of transnational corporations: international legal aspects: abstract of the dissertation of Candidate of Legal Sciences]. M., 2003. 33 p. (In Russian)Murashko L. O. Aksiologicheskoe izmerenie protsessa pravoobrazovaniya: istoriya i sovremennost: diss. … dokt. yurid. nauk [The axiological dimension of the process of law formation: history and modernity: dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences]. M., 2015. 41 p. (In Russian)Murashko L. O. Aksiologicheskoe izmerenie protsessa pravoobrazovaniya: istoriya i sovremennost: diss. … dokt. yurid. nauk [The axiological dimension of the process of law formation: history and modernity: dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences]. M., 2015. 41 p. (In Russian)Pridvorov N. A., Trofimov V. V. Pravoobrazovanie i pravoobrazuyushchie faktory v prave [The law formation and law-forming factors in the legislation]. M.: Norma, 2016. 400 p. (In Russian)Pridvorov N. A., Trofimov V. V. Pravoobrazovanie i pravoobrazuyushchie faktory v prave [The law formation and law-forming factors in the legislation]. M.: Norma, 2016. 400 p. (In Russian)Romanenko R. A. Problema sootnosheniya yazykovoy i ontologicheskoy kartin mira v filosofii Parmenida [Th e problem of the correlation between the linguistic and ontological view of the world in the philosophy of Parmenides] // Nauchnye issledovaniya i razrabotki molodykh uchenykh [Research and innovation by young scientists]. 2015. No. 3. Pp. 134–137. (In Russian)Romanenko R. A. Problema sootnosheniya yazykovoy i ontologicheskoy kartin mira v filosofii Parmenida [Th e problem of the correlation between the linguistic and ontological view of the world in the philosophy of Parmenides] // Nauchnye issledovaniya i razrabotki molodykh uchenykh [Research and innovation by young scientists]. 2015. No. 3. Pp. 134–137. (In Russian)Rybakov O. Yu. Chelovek, pravo, kultura, tekhnologii: novaya paradigma vzaimodeystviya? [The human, law, culture, and technology: a new paradigm of interaction?] // Osnovnye tendentsii razvitiya sovremennogo prava: problemy teorii i praktiki: materialy VI Natsionalnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii, Kazan, 25 fevralya 2022 goda. Kazan: Universitet upravleniya “TISBI” [The main trends in the development of modern law: problems of theory and practice: materials of the VI National Scientific and Practical Conference, Kazan, February 25, 2022. Kazan: “TISBI” University of Management], 2022. Pp. 194–201. (In Russian)Rybakov O. Yu. Chelovek, pravo, kultura, tekhnologii: novaya paradigma vzaimodeystviya? [The human, law, culture, and technology: a new paradigm of interaction?] // Osnovnye tendentsii razvitiya sovremennogo prava: problemy teorii i praktiki: materialy VI Natsionalnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii, Kazan, 25 fevralya 2022 goda. Kazan: Universitet upravleniya “TISBI” [The main trends in the development of modern law: problems of theory and practice: materials of the VI National Scientific and Practical Conference, Kazan, February 25, 2022. Kazan: “TISBI” University of Management], 2022. Pp. 194–201. (In Russian)Shelton D. International Law and Relative Normativity in International Law, Edited by Malcolm D. Evans. Oxford University Press. 2003. 833 p.Shelton D. International Law and Relative Normativity in International Law, Edited by Malcolm D. Evans. Oxford University Press. 2003. 833 p.Spinoza B. Etika [The ethics] / per. s lat. V. I. Modestova. Mn: Kharvest, M.: AST, 2001. 336 p. (In Russian)Spinoza B. Etika [The ethics] / per. s lat. V. I. Modestova. Mn: Kharvest, M.: AST, 2001. 336 p. (In Russian)Vedeneev Yu. A. Grammatika pravoporyadka [Th e Grammar of Law Enforcement]. M.: RG-Press, 2018. 232 p. (In Russian)Vedeneev Yu. A. Grammatika pravoporyadka [Th e Grammar of Law Enforcement]. M.: RG-Press, 2018. 232 p. (In Russian)Vedeneev Yu. A. Yuridicheskaya kartina mira: mezhdu dolzhnym i sushchim [The legal view of the world: between the proper and the actual] // Lex Russica. 2014. No. 6. Pp. 641–654. (In Russian)Vedeneev Yu. A. Yuridicheskaya kartina mira: mezhdu dolzhnym i sushchim [The legal view of the world: between the proper and the actual] // Lex Russica. 2014. No. 6. Pp. 641–654. (In Russian)Williams A. C. Civil Society Initiatives and “Soft Law” in the Oil & Gas Industry // New York University Journal of International Law & Politics. Vol. 36. (2004). Pp. 461–477.Williams A. C. Civil Society Initiatives and “Soft Law” in the Oil & Gas Industry // New York University Journal of International Law & Politics. Vol. 36. (2004). Pp. 461–477.Zimnenko B. L. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo i pravovaya sistema Rossii: diss. … d.yu.n. [The International law and the legal system of Russia: Dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences] M., 2006. 376 p. (In Russian)Zimnenko B. L. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo i pravovaya sistema Rossii: diss. … d.yu.n. [The International law and the legal system of Russia: Dissertation of Doctor of Legal Sciences] M., 2006. 376 p. (In Russian)

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.